Thursday, August 30, 2018

God's Machiavellian Machinations


A classic question is how Hashem could have punished the Egyptians for enslaving the Bnei Yisroel when He Himself had orchestrated their slavery in Egypt. How could God have punished Pharaoh for not releasing the Israelites when He intervened and hardened Pharaoh's heart?

There are various answers given, but I think I've discovered the real reason.

Cesare Borgia, the fifteenth-century Duke of Valentinois, is thought to be the main inspiration for Machiavelli's "The Prince." Borgia did whatever he thought would best lead to the realization of his goals, regardless of the morality of his actions. In one instance, he ordered one of his generals to snuff out a rebellion. The harsh and violent methods the general used under Borgia's orders made the general widely hated. After the rebellion was put down, Borgia had the general executed for his crimes. This made the people love him and his underlings fear him, exactly the result that served Borgia best.

Hashem is omniscient. Unlike us puny humans, He doesn't have to wait for historical developments or talented writers to produce works like "The Prince" to know the best methods for manipulating the public.  Long before Cesare Borgia and Machiavelli, Hashem knew that the best way to get the people to love and fear you is to have someone else do your dirty work, and then punish them for it.

4 comments:

  1. Sure sounds like God's unjust. Also can you PLEASE make a post refuting the viewpoint that reality except for toireh is "vanity and mistaken worth"(Ramchal,Messilat Yesharim chapter 1).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I plan to go through the Mesilas Yesharim one of these days.

      Delete
    2. Thanks. It'd be really nice if you'd post more often as well. Your previous post got >40 comments. Also how big is your readership?

      Delete
  2. Did YAHUAH punish Khemet for enslaving them or for not releasing them when told to do so?

    ReplyDelete